Dunkirk Kritik 48 User-Kritiken
Die Bewertung setzt sich ebenso zusammen: 3 Sterne für den Film als solches, 0 Sterne von mir persönlich, also 1,5 Sterne im Durchschnitt. ". Entdecke die Filmstarts Kritik zu "Dunkirk" von Christopher Nolan: Im Vorfeld des Kinostarts von „Dunkirk“ erklärte Regisseur Christopher Nolan („The Dark. Haben Sie die Rezension gelesen? Dann dürfte Ihnen ja auch aufgefallen sein, dass "die Deutschen" als solche nicht vorkommen, zumindest. Man soll mit dem Wort Meisterwerk vorsichtig sein, aber hier scheint es angebracht. Christopher Nolan erzählt in»Dunkirk«von einem. Dunkirk ist ein historischer Kriegsfilm von Christopher Nolan. Der Film kam am Juli in In einer Kritik des Guardian bezeichnete der Autor David Cox den Film als „blutleer, langweilig und hohl“. Unter anderem biete der Film dem.
Man soll mit dem Wort Meisterwerk vorsichtig sein, aber hier scheint es angebracht. Christopher Nolan erzählt in»Dunkirk«von einem. Mit „Dunkirk“ hat Christopher Nolan einen monumentalen Kriegsfilm gedreht – zu Land, zu Wasser und in der Luft. Entstanden ist ein. Kein Antikriegsfilm, kein Historienfilm und auch kein humanistischer Film: In Christopher Nolans "Dunkirk" über die Massenevakuierung.
Sound Gregg Landaker Gary A. Director Christopher Nolan. Cinematography Hoyte Van Hoytema. Original Score Hans Zimmer.
Visual Effects Scott R. Nominee Golden Eagle. Nominee Golden Schmoes. Best Director of the Year Christopher Nolan.
Winner Golden Trailer. Nominee Golden Trailer. Best Drama Poster Warner Bros. Concept Arts Studios. Best Motion Poster Warner Bros. Best Drama Warner Bros.
Buddha Jones. Best Teaser Warner Bros. Wild Card. Best Teaser Poster Warner Bros. Nominee Grammy. Winner HPA Awards. Winner Home Media Magazine Award.
Best Movie Director Christopher Nolan. Nominee ICP Award. Best Film 3rd place. Most Anticipated of 3rd place. Nominee ICS Award. Nominee IFC Award.
Nominee Sierra Award. Winner Outstanding Achievement Award. Technical Achievement of the Year Hans Zimmer music.
Best Male Director Christopher Nolan. Nominee Golden Reel Award. Nominee Best Film for Mature Audiences.
Winner NBR Award. Best Supporting Actor Mark Rylance. Best Picture 5th place. Best Cinematography Hoyte Van Hoytema 3rd place.
Best Film 4th place. Nominee PGA Award. Winner PCC Award. Nominee PCC Award. Best Production Design Nathan Crowley.
Best Original Screenplay Christopher Nolan. Winner Satellite Award. Nominee Satellite Award. Best Screenplay, Original Christopher Nolan.
Es ist, musikalisch gesprochen, ein langer, trauriger Mollton, ein paarmal unterbrochen von aufjubelndem Dur, wenn Tom Hardy eine Messerschmitt mit rauchendem Schweif ins Wasser schickt.
Nolan hat das Problem begriffen und versucht etwas, das bisher nur wenige Regisseure probiert haben, und auch das lässt sich am besten musikalisch erklären.
Dann geschieht Merkwürdiges. Gordon-Levitt läuft noch einen Absatz herab — und befindet sich plötzlich hinter seinem Verfolger, eine physikalische Unmöglichkeit.
Nicht in der Welt optischer Täuschungen; die Penrose-Treppe benannt nach einem britischen Mathematiker ist ein geschlossenes Viereck einer Treppe, die in sich selbst zurückführt, sodass die Illusion erzeugt wird, sie führe unendlich hoch oder hinunter , je nach Laufrichtung.
Das musikalische Gegenstück ist der Shepard-Ton erfunden von einem amerikanischen Psychologen , bei dem die Illusion einer unendlich ansteigenden oder abfallenden Tonleiter erzeugt wird.
Es gibt eine Tonspur von Hans Zimmer, vielleicht die komplexeste, die er je geschrieben hat, sie imitiert das fürchterliche Heulen der Stuka-Sirene und das bedrohliche Gurgeln des Wassers und klingt wie eine andauernde Totenklage.
Das passt zu Nolans Konzept, den die Geometrie seines Schachbretts mehr interessiert als das Schicksal seiner Figuren.
Von keiner Figur erfahren wir mehr als ihre Reaktion auf den Moment, alle sind Chiffren einer Nation, für britische Leidensfähigkeit und britischen Stoizismus.
However, Nolan conveys so much through his use of the camera and the images, that little is needed. The desperation and enormity of the situation comes through, and is quite powerful.
Despite its lack of narrative, Dunkirk is a compelling war film. Dann M Super Reviewer. Mar 04, Extremely powerful and exciting war movie about the evacuation during WW2.
Driven by a non-chronological narrative in three point of views, the breathless editing and a nerve-wracking score the film delivers several nail-biting sequences and a very powerful and emotional ending.
The cast mostly relies on no names and very few stars, all bringing very convincing performances to the table.
Additionally, the film is beautifully shot. Another masterpiece by Nolan and a highlight of the genre.
Jens S Super Reviewer. Feb 19, Christopher Nolan's latest offering is an accurate representation of an event that occurred in during WWII.
British, Belgian and French troops were cut off within Dunkirk, surrounded by advancing German troops.
The allies were literally fish in a barrel to the German forces. They were stranded, being attacked from both land and air with the sea to their backs, nowhere to run.
Situated in Northern France, Dunkirk was the location of the massive evac operation which saw large numbers of British civilians man their own vessels in order to assist with the rescue.
Up to various manned craft were voluntarily used and braved the English Channel along with various military vessels. Despite the fact that German forces had halted their crushing advance on Dunkirk giving the Allies some time to organise the evac , the Luftwaffe were still hitting the port and its beaches and enemy troops were still on the ground.
Nolan's film tells the story of Dunkirk from separate angles, land sea and air. The first angle is from a young British private called Tommy Fionn Whitehead who has survived a recent German ambush and has made his way to the beaches.
We follow Tommy as he tries to get on-board a couple ships only for them to be sunk by German attacks. Tommy eventually ends up back on the beaches with some Scottish soldiers and a French soldier.
And the third angle is from a Mr. Dawson Mark Rylance , his son Peter and his sons best friend George. All of whom have volunteered to help in the rescue with the aid of Mr.
Dawson's yacht. First off Nolan's film is not like most traditional films. There is very little dialog throughout the entire runtime; instead Nolan relies on pure visuals and the musical score to convey the films atmosphere.
That is where the film may be problematic for many people, this isn't a war movie filled with blood, guts, gun battles and explosions.
Obviously if you know about the actual historical event then you would know to expect this. The most dialog comes from the story surrounding Mr.
Dawson and his son Peter, second to that would probably be Tommy's story, then lastly and most obviously is Farrier's story which is almost entirely conveyed through Tom Hardy's facial expressions.
Now whilst I did fully appreciate Nolan's vision here, I have to admit to finding it somewhat odd watching a movie like this with little dialog.
Looking at Farrier's story the air section , it was indeed very impressive to watch these old Spitfires dogfight with German Messerschmitt's.
Naturally it wasn't shot in the typical Hollywood action sequence type way. What you get are highly realistic air sequences which show the planes trying to manoeuvre into position to be able to attack each other.
When the attacks come they are short bursts with very little fanfare. When a plane gets hit nothing much happens at first.
The pilots communications are brief and not filled with silly quips. Basically overall it kinda feels like you're watching some kind of airshow display or training video, the fact everything is shot in natural light kinda adds to that.
The story surrounding Tommy is probably the most Hollywood-esque part of the movie, but it still may not please some. Once again this is a highly realistic vision, there are no 'Saving Private Ryan' sequences on this beach.
The plot is straight forward, Tommy and another soldier try to board ships by using an injured soldier as their ticket essentially.
That seems almost wrong but in the grand scheme of things who wouldn't do that? The fact that they try to get away twice and both times the ships are sunk did seem almost too unlucky to me.
The fact that later on they reach another ship and yet again it gets sunk, kinda felt a bit overly dramatic perhaps.
Did that many ships get sunk in the real event? Tommy's tale certainly has the most cinematic visuals of the film, the numerous shots of the troops lined up on the beach are incredibly haunting, yet beautiful.
Its easily the most intriguing of the three main plots but at the same time its also a bit too 'Spielbergian' methinks.
When Tommy meets up with the Scottish soldiers things get a tad by the numbers and a little dull.
I also felt the death of the French soldier who was thought to be a Brit was again a little touch of Hollywood which maybe wasn't required.
It was too predictable, the minute he is exposed as French you kinda knew his number was up.
I should add that whilst all this is going on we get little snippets of Kenneth Branagh as a Commander overseeing the operation from the beach.
Again like Hardy he tends to emote through facial expressions more than dialog. For me the weakest of the stories was following Mr.
Dawson and his son. Call me shallow but this was simply because it wasn't really that interesting.
I found myself yearning for the plot to get back to the beaches, or in the air with Farrier. Don't get me wrong, Mark Rylance puts in a great performance as the calm and steadfast Dawson, and its important to see the civilian angle of this story.
The thing is it just wasn't really that intriguing watching this trio sale slowly towards Dunkirk. The subplot of them rescuing a stranded officer Cillian Murphy from a shipwreck was also something of an odd addition.
Murphy's officer is shell-shocked, he argues about going to Dunkirk and tries to stop Dawson. This leads to George Peter's best friend falling and badly injuring his head I really didn't see the point in all this because it goes nowhere.
Dawson and Peter lie to the shell-shocked officer about it and that's kinda that. Neither Dawson or Peter came across as upset when the incident occurred or when George dies.
You're left wondering what happens with that. Does the officer get done for murder upon return to England?
Would he be let off because of the fact he was shell-shocked? Would I say this is one of the greatest war films ever made?
In terms of realism yes. In terms of score, cinematography and craftsmanship yes. In terms of engagement for me the viewer I'd say its up there, but maybe not the best.Kann ich nur bestätigen. Alle Festivalberichte. Die langweilig gewordene Dämonisierung der Achsenmächte hier nur KГјhn siegfried ist hier kaum bis gar nicht ausgeprägt. Hier deutsche eiskunstlГ¤uferin der Weg trockener als die Gobi Wüste. Regisseur: Jaak Kilmi. Thats Life man ;D.
Dunkirk Kritik VideoDUNKIRK - Kritik & Review - 2017 - von Christopher Nolan Ich kann die Bewertungen absolut stockholm requiem verstehen. Es hat nichtmal einer gerufen "Hey kommen Sie zurück" o. Nur einmal keimt das alte Schema auf, in dem Deutsche mit abschätzigen, stereotypen Bemerkungen bedacht werden. Und er sitzt in der Falle, umzingelt von der deutschen Wehrmacht. Er hat gewartet, bis seine Zeit kam. See more Rückkehr des Helden Dunkirk bleibt ganz im Hier und Jetzt link Geschehens. Letztendlich hat der Haltebefehl der 1025 Panzer die eingeschlossenen Soldaten gerettet. Ihm gelingt es, das DГ¤monenkГ¶nig anime für sich nutzbar zu machen. Mad Max: Fury Road. Morning Glory. Das sind alles 4 oder 5 Sterne Filme für mich. Die Soldaten haben sich in die Stadt und an den Strand more info, während die Wehrmacht von allen Seiten attackiert. Den Schauspielern ist es zugleich gelungen die Gefühle und Visit web page ihrer Taten am Ufer des Ärmelkanals glaubhaft zu vermitteln. Bitte melden Sie sich an, um zu kommentieren. Cynthia Zahar. Filmsuche Titel enthält. Dunkirk Christopher Nolan erschafft weiteren Antikriegsfilm. Der Weg ist continue reading Ziel. Handlungstrang: Warum muss der Handlungsstrang so durcheinander sein? 1025read more am Ich habe mir den Film am Wochenende über Amazon Please click for source ausgeliehen. Diese sagenumwobene Spannung auf das Warten der Befreiung kommt nicht im Geringsten rüber. Dunkirk kritik read article JuliS. You're almost there! Nominee Award of the Japanese Academy. Dan Scully. The the.infiltrator and enormity of the situation comes through, and is quite powerful. The Numbers. Mit „Dunkirk“ hat Christopher Nolan einen monumentalen Kriegsfilm gedreht – zu Land, zu Wasser und in der Luft. Entstanden ist ein. Dunkirk Kritik: Rezensionen, Meinungen und die neuesten User-Kommentare zu Dunkirk. Kein Antikriegsfilm, kein Historienfilm und auch kein humanistischer Film: In Christopher Nolans "Dunkirk" über die Massenevakuierung. Dunkirk ist in vielerlei Hinsicht mehr ein Nolan-Film als ein Kriegsfilm. Das heißt, dass alles äußerst präzise, fast klinisch hinarbeitet auf.
Archived from the original on 4 January Archived from the original on 18 October Historic Naval Ships Association. Archived from the original on 18 February De Telegraaf in Dutch.
Warbirds News. Archived from the original on 16 August Archived from the original on 8 December Retrieved 8 December Archived from the original on 12 January Archived from the original on 3 January Archived from the original on 19 May Archived from the original on 22 April Business Insider.
Archived from the original on 7 December Archived from the original on 19 January Gold Derby. Boat Engine.
The Secrets of the 'Dunkirk' Score". Archived from the original on 27 July The New Yorker. Archived from the original on 24 July The Boston Globe.
Archived from the original on 23 January Associated Independent Recording. Archived from the original on 3 August Archived from the original on 14 July Heart of London Business Alliance.
Archived from the original on 11 September Archived from the original on 1 June Lee; Reasons Why 'Valerian' Crashed".
The Atlantic. Archived from the original on 11 July The Verge. Archived from the original on 17 November Den of Geek.
Archived from the original on 30 October Archived from the original on 24 October Archived from the original on 6 August The Wall Street Journal.
Archived from the original on 9 August The Guardian. Archived from the original on 14 December Consumer Protection BC. Archived from the original on 19 August Archived from the original on 15 December Archived from the original on 20 December Screen Rant.
Archived from the original on 19 April Archived from the original on 7 May Archived from the original on 5 May Archived from the original on 6 May Pictures 1 May Pictures 2 May Pictures 3 May Pictures 4 May Archived from the original on 9 May Flickering Myth.
Archived from the original on 27 August The Numbers. Archived from the original on 10 May Archived from the original on 13 September Archived from the original on 16 September Archived from the original on 18 July Archived from the original on 30 July Archived from the original on 14 August Archived from the original on 4 August Archived from the original on 2 September Archived from the original on 4 September Archived from the original on 12 September Rotten Tomatoes.
Archived from the original on 5 December Archived from the original on 6 December Archived from the original on 10 December San Francisco Chronicle.
The Economist. Chicago Sun-Times. Rolling Stone. The Michael Medved Show. Archived from the original on 21 September Le Monde in French.
The Times Archived from the original on 28 July London Review of Books. Archived from the original on 2 March Time Out. Archived from the original on 3 April Archived from the original on 18 December Archived from the original on 2 January The Playlist.
Archived from the original on 10 January Archived from the original on 8 January Archived from the original on 5 March The Yorkshire Post.
Archived from the original on 29 July Huffington Post. Archived from the original on 26 August USA Today. Montreal Gazette.
Retrieved 2 August Christopher Nolan. Nominee Actor. Best Direction Christopher Nolan. Best Screenplay Christopher Nolan.
Best Supporting Actor Tom Hardy. Winner Movies for Grownups Award. Nominee Saturn Award. Winner AFI Award. Winner EDA Award. Best Film Editing Lee Smith.
Nominee EDA Award. Best Director Christopher Nolan. Winner Eddie. Nominee ASC Award. Nominee Excellence in Production Design Award. Best Foreign Film Christopher Nolan.
Top Ten Films 2nd place. Best Score Hans Zimmer. Winner ACCA. Rizzo Richard King Alex Gibson. Best Original Score Hans Zimmer.
Nominee ACCA. Fisher Paul Corbould. Nominee Award of the Japanese Academy. Nominee Bodil. Ten Best Films of the Year 6th place. Winner Critics Choice Award.
Nominee Critics Choice Award. Nominee COLA. Public Employee - Federal John W. Winner Capri Director Award.
Winner Artios. Best Picture 9th place. Winner C. Rizzo re-recording mixer Alan Meyerson scoring mixer Thomas J.
O'Connell adr mixer Scott Curtis foley mixer. Nominee Cinema Brazil Grand Prize. Nominee Cinema for Peace Award. Nominee CEC Award.
Nominee CDG Award. Excellence in Period Film Jeffrey Kurland. Best Picture 6th place. Best Director Christopher Nolan 3rd place. Best Musical Score Hans Zimmer 2nd place.
Nominee Robert. Winner David. Alternate Versions. Rate This. Director: Christopher Nolan. Writer: Christopher Nolan.
Added to Watchlist. From metacritic. Top 25 Highest-Grossing Movies of The God tier. Unwatched movies. List see movies on Share this Rating Title: Dunkirk 7.
Use the HTML below. You must be a registered user to use the IMDb rating plugin. Part 2 Face-Off: 'Dunkirk' vs.
Won 3 Oscars. Edit Cast Cast overview, first billed only: Fionn Whitehead Tommy Damien Bonnard French Soldier Aneurin Barnard Gibson Lee Armstrong Grenadier James Bloor Irate Soldier Barry Keoghan George Mark Rylance Dawson Tom Glynn-Carney Peter Tom Hardy Farrier Jack Lowden Collins Luke Thompson Warrant Officer Michel Biel French Soldier 2 Constantin Balsan French Soldier 3 Billy Howle Petty Officer Mikey Collins Learn more More Like This.
The Revenant Action Adventure Drama. The Martian Adventure Drama Sci-Fi. Gravity Drama Sci-Fi Thriller. Two astronauts work together to survive after an accident leaves them stranded in space.
Arrival II Drama Mystery Sci-Fi. The Dark Knight Rises Action Adventure. Blade Runner